“However beautiful the strategy is, you should occasionally look at the results.”

Understanding the health of Canada’s innovation ecosystem requires a close look at data and metrics, allowing us to assess better what and where the challenges are. There are multiple levels of analysis, from the macroeconomic perspective (which we will discuss here) to the very tactical (which we will discuss in the next post as we dive into issues). A simple macroeconomic model to evaluate performance of the ecosystem involves three metrics: Entrepreneurship Participation, Productivity, and Prosperity.

Participation (Entrepreneurship) “BDC’s Index of New Entrepreneurial Activity measures the yearly appearance of new independent workers who hire employees as a proportion of the total labor force. Statistics Canada’s monthly Labour Force Survey provides data for the Index. Entrepreneurship is a primary contributor to value and wealth in the economy.

Productivity measures how efficiently entrepreneurial activities convert into economic value. The Bank of Canada calculates Productivity on three principal elements:

  • Labour Productivity (measures output per hour worked),
  • Multifactor Productivity (MFP): (overall efficiency with which both labor and capital are used together),
  • Capital Productivity (measures output per unit of capital, showing how effectively investments contribute to economic output).

Prosperity The Legatum Prosperity Index defines prosperity as a holistic concept considering wealth and well-being. This definition goes beyond traditional measures of economic success, such as GDP, and encompasses factors like social capital, effective governance, education, health, safety, and security. The Index seeks to encourage a more comprehensive understanding of prosperity by considering many factors contributing to human flourishing.

Using data ensures we move beyond anecdotes and form policies rooted in facts. The simple macroeconomic model is a streamlined framework to evaluate the Canadian innovation ecosystem. Entrepreneurship Participation is the input to the model. Productivity measures the conversion of value creation to economic output. Prosperity is an indicator of economic well being.

This structured approach creates several key macroeconomic data points. Organizations like BDC, the Bank of Canada, and the Legatum Institute already collect this data. By tapping into this wealth of information, policymakers can easily track and strengthen Canada’s innovation landscape.

BDC Entrepreneurship Participation Index

BDC’s Entrepreneurship participation index reveals a concerning decline in Canada’s rate of new entrepreneurs. This trend could lead to serious long-term consequences, such as reduced job creation and slowed economic growth. At this time, I have more questions than answers, but the urgency of this issue is clear.

  • Why is entrepreneurship in Canada declining?
  • Which industries are most affected?
  • What specific barriers do individuals face when launching businesses?

Identifying roadblocks, such as access to funding or regulatory challenges, can help policymakers encourage more entrepreneurial activity. In my research, barriers to entrepreneurship are a recurring theme.

 

Canadian Productivity – Time to break the glass

The graph to the left has raised the alarm in many parts of Canada. The Bank of Canada considers Productivity a national emergency and has titled a recent report, “Time to Break the Glass: Fixing Canada’s Productivity Problem.” Senior Deputy Governor Carolyn Rogers presented this report during a speech at the Halifax Partnership event in March 2024. The CFIB has also raised some concerns about Canadian Productivity. The bottom line is that Canada’s productivity problem has worsened over time and has appeared to be in freefall since COVID-19.

 

Canadians’ Declining Prosperity

Prosperity is crucial to a nation’s well-being, as it extends beyond material wealth to include essential elements like social capital, equality of opportunity, and effective governance. I like this metric because it is a global comparison and ranks prosperity relative to the rest of the world. While Canada ranks well in the Legatum Prosperity Index, our ranking has declined since 2013.

The prosperity index graph shows Canada’s overall prosperity ranking from 2007 to 2023. The trend is concerning. In 2013, Canada ranked third overall in global prosperity. However, our ranking has declined to 15th or 16th in the past decade.

Canadian Innovation Ecosystem Metrics – Lack of entrepreneurship leads the decline

Canada has issues with all indicators: participation, productivity, and prosperity. Based on this macro-level analysis of Canada’s innovation ecosystem, the major contributor to the decline in productivity and prosperity is the need for more entrepreneurial participation in the Canadian economy. If you can improve the entrepreneurship participation rate (and success), the result will be improvements in productivity and prosperity. However, macroeconomic analysis is high-level and coarse. You must dig into the details to improve policy that facilitates entrepreneurship.

My next post will dive into the issues that may inhibit entrepreneurship participation in Canada.